Hello friends! Today, I’m going to talk about something super interesting: SW vs BM exterior paint for siding! Yes, we’re diving into the differences between Sherwin-Williams (SW) and Benjamin Moore (BM) when it comes to choosing the best paint for your home’s siding. You might be wondering, “What’s the big deal?” Well, choosing the right exterior paint is like picking the perfect outfit for your home. It can totally change its vibe and make it look awesome for years!
Let’s make this super simple and fun, and I’ll throw in a handy table to make things clearer!
| Criteria | Sherwin-Williams (SW) | Benjamin Moore (BM) |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | Very durable, even in harsh weather | Long-lasting and fade-resistant |
| Color Selection | 1,700+ color choices | Over 3,500+ shades available |
| Price Range | Mid to high range | Generally high range |
| Application | Smooth, thick coverage | Easy to apply and forgiving |
| Finish Quality | Smooth and durable finish | Premium, elegant finish |
| Environmental Friendliness | Low-VOC options available | Eco-friendly, many zero-VOC paints |
SW vs BM Exterior Paint for Siding: Which One is Better?
Alright, so first up, both Sherwin-Williams (SW) and Benjamin Moore (BM) are top dogs in the paint world. People swear by these brands when they want to give their home’s siding a fresh, long-lasting look. But which one is better?
Sherwin-Williams is known for its amazing durability. This is especially great if you live somewhere with tough weather—rain, snow, blazing sun—you name it, SW can handle it! Plus, the paint is pretty thick and goes on smoothly. Benjamin Moore, on the other hand, is famous for its color variety. With over 3,500 shades, you’ll never run out of options! Their paint also tends to have a more refined, luxurious finish.
Both paints offer low-VOC or zero-VOC options, so they’re better for the environment and safer for your family! However, BM might win a tiny bit here because of its wider selection of eco-friendly choices.
Best Paint for Weather Protection on Siding
When it comes to protecting your house from the weather, both SW and BM offer great options, but they do it a little differently.
Sherwin-Williams is known for its WeatherShield and SuperPaint lines. These paints are made to stand up to extreme conditions. Whether it’s blistering heat or freezing cold, SW will stay strong. It also has built-in mildew resistance, which is great if you live in a humid place. You don’t want mold growing on your house, right?
Benjamin Moore’s Aura and Regal Select lines are no slouches either! They offer superior protection from fading, even in bright sunlight. Plus, BM paints are known to hold up well against rain and other wet conditions. The color won’t fade easily, and it’ll keep your house looking fresh longer.
Color Choices: Why It Matters More Than You Think!
Colors matter a lot when painting your siding, right? I mean, it’s what everyone sees first!
Sherwin-Williams offers about 1,700 colors. That’s a lot! They have bold colors, soft shades, neutrals—you name it. They also offer something called ColorSnap, which is a tool that helps you pick the right colors based on your home’s design and style. It’s super helpful if you’re someone who’s indecisive (like me sometimes!).
But then, Benjamin Moore comes in strong with over 3,500 colors! They have this beautiful line called Historical Colors which are timeless and elegant. Plus, they have their Color Preview system that lets you explore different combinations, so you can make sure your house will stand out in the neighborhood.
If you love having a TON of choices, Benjamin Moore is the winner here. But, if you find picking from too many options overwhelming, Sherwin-Williams has enough variety to keep you satisfied without being too much!
Application Process: Which Paint is Easier to Apply?
Now, let’s talk about how easy it is to actually paint your siding with these two brands.
Sherwin-Williams paints are known for their smooth coverage. The paint is thick, so you don’t have to worry about streaks or having to paint the same spot over and over. Even if you’re not a pro at painting, SW makes it pretty easy.
Benjamin Moore is famous for being super user-friendly. A lot of people say it’s forgiving if you make a mistake because it blends really well as you paint. So, even if you’re doing it yourself, BM makes you feel like a pro!
If you’re looking for an easy and smooth painting experience, both are good, but BM might have the edge because it’s a bit more forgiving for beginners.
Cost and Value: Are You Getting What You Pay For?
Let’s be real. Price matters. You don’t want to spend an arm and a leg just for paint, right?
Sherwin-Williams is generally in the mid to high price range. You can expect to pay around $60-$80 per gallon for premium lines like SuperPaint or Duration. Yes, it’s a bit pricey, but SW paints last a long time, so you won’t have to repaint often.
Benjamin Moore is usually on the higher end. Their top-tier paints like Aura can go for about $70-$90 per gallon. But here’s the thing: BM’s paints are often seen as more luxurious and provide an elegant finish. So, while you might pay more upfront, it’s an investment in quality.
In terms of value, both brands are worth the money. It just depends on your budget and whether you prefer a more budget-friendly option (SW) or want to splurge a bit for that extra touch of luxury (BM).
Eco-Friendliness: Which Paint is Greener?
Caring for the environment is a big deal these days, and both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore are aware of that.
Sherwin-Williams offers low-VOC options, which means their paints release fewer harmful chemicals into the air. This is better for the planet and for you, especially if you have kids or pets at home. SW also has a line called Harmony, which is designed to purify the air inside your home—pretty cool, right?
Benjamin Moore, though, takes eco-friendliness to another level. They have several zero-VOC paints, like their Natura line, which is super safe and environmentally friendly. You don’t have to worry about any toxic fumes. Plus, BM’s paints are known for being durable, so you won’t need to repaint as often, reducing waste in the long run!
If you’re all about going green, BM might be the better option with its zero-VOC paints and overall commitment to eco-friendliness.
Which Paint Should You Pick for Your Siding?
Both Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore offer fantastic paints for your siding, but they shine in slightly different ways.
If you want durability and paint that can handle crazy weather, go with Sherwin-Williams. It’s perfect for people who want tough, long-lasting paint that won’t fade or peel easily.
On the other hand, if you care more about luxurious color choices and a premium finish, Benjamin Moore is the way to go. With thousands of colors and a smooth, elegant finish, your house will definitely be the star of the block!
In the end, both are great choices—you really can’t go wrong. Think about your budget, your color needs, and whether you’re painting yourself or hiring a pro. Then, pick the paint that feels right for you! If you’re still stuck, maybe get some samples from both and test them on a small section of your siding to see which one you fall in love with.